E46 Knowledge Base · Volume 3
5 More Essential E46
How-To Guides

Oil filter housing gasket, front wheel bearing, cabin air filter, power steering diagnosis and flush, and accessory belt replacement. 15 guides total. Zero bullshit.

11
Oil Filter Housing Gasket — The oil leak BMW forgot to tell you about
Route AM52TU · M54Intermediate2–3 hrs · $30–85
12
Front Wheel Bearing Replacement — Hub assembly swap, full procedure
Route BAll E46 RWDIntermediate2–4 hrs · $100–160
13
Cabin Air Filter — 10 minute job, $30 part, skip the $100 dealer charge
Route AAll E46Total beginner10 min · $20–30
14
Power Steering Diagnosis & Fluid Flush — Find the leak, fix the whine
Route A–BAll E46Beginner1–2 hrs · $20–50
15
Accessory Belt & Tensioner — Pre-emptive strike before you're stranded
Route AM52TU · M54Beginner1–2 hrs · $40–80
Guide 11 Route A Intermediate

E46 Oil Filter Housing Gasket —
The oil leak BMW forgot to tell you about

Fits: 1999–2006 E46 · M52TU · M54
Time: 2–3 hours
Difficulty: Intermediate
Cost: $30–85
The oil filter housing gasket is the single most common oil leak on the M54 engine. It's a profile rubber gasket that shrinks and hardens with age, allowing oil to weep down the front of the engine. Turner Motorsport calls it one of the most common service jobs in their shop. The VANOS oil line that connects to the housing is the second most common leak point — replace both at the same time. You're doing this job anyway, so do it right.
📷
Photo: oil filter housing location on M54 — front of engine, passenger side
Show oil residue pattern down front of engine — classic OFHG failure signature
Symptoms: Oil weeping from the front of the engine near the oil filter housing, burning oil smell, oil pressure light flickering on cold starts (sign of more advanced failure — the non-return valve may be worn), oil pooling on the underside of the engine. If you see oil on the front of your M54, this is the first place to look.
Cold start oil pressure light — separate issue: If your oil pressure light takes 3–4 seconds to go out on a cold start, the non-return valve inside the housing is worn. The valve body develops a groove from the plastic fins over thousands of starts. When replacing the OFHG, rotate the valve so the fins don't align with the worn groove. If the groove is too deep, replace the entire housing.
Parts list — pick your budget
Budget build · $30–40
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
OEM profile gasket (rubber)11421719855~$18Turner Motorsport
VANOS line crush washers (x2)07119963200~$4Amazon
Oil filter cap O-ring11427512300~$6Amazon
Total~$28
Complete kit · $75–85
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
ECS complete OFHG replacement kit11421719855KT1~$82ECS Tuning
Includes gasket, VANOS line, crush washers, O-rings, oil filter — everything for a complete service
Total~$82
Viton upgrade · $45–55
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Bavauto Viton OFHG (DuPont synthetic rubber)BAV-21719855V~$30ECS Tuning
Viton synthetic rubber withstands higher temps and lasts significantly longer than OEM rubber. "Don't replace it twice."
VANOS line + crush washers11411722688~$20ECS Tuning
Total~$50
Tools required
36mm socketOil filter cap removal
32mm spanner wrenchFan clutch — reverse thread
10mm socket + extensionsHousing bolts
17mm wrenchVANOS line banjo bolt
Brake cleaner + ragsClean all mating surfaces
Drain panOil will spill when housing comes off
Torque wrenchHousing bolts 10 Nm
Pick toolRemove old gasket from groove
Procedure
1
Drain the oil and remove the fan + shroud
Do an oil change at the same time — you're this deep anyway. Drain the oil first. Then remove the fan clutch (32mm, reverse thread — clockwise = loosen) and fan shroud. This gives you working room at the front of the engine where the oil filter housing sits.
Do the oil change while you're here. The oil is already drained, the engine is already apart. Fresh oil + new filter adds $20 to the job and takes 5 minutes. This is when you do it.
2
Remove the oil filter cap and filter
Use a 36mm socket to unscrew the oil filter cap. The filter and cap come out together. Set them aside. You'll see the oil filter housing body still mounted to the engine with several bolts around its perimeter. This is what you need to remove.
📷
Photo: oil filter cap removed — housing body visible with bolts around perimeter
3
Disconnect the VANOS oil line
The VANOS oil line connects to the side of the oil filter housing with a banjo bolt. Use a 17mm wrench to remove the banjo bolt. Have a rag ready — oil will seep out. Note there are two copper crush washers on the banjo bolt — one on each side. These are single-use and must be replaced.
New crush washers every time. Crush washers are designed to deform once for a seal. Reusing them causes leaks. They cost $2. Buy them. Use them.
4
Remove the oil filter housing
Remove all the bolts holding the housing to the engine block — typically 5–6 bolts around the perimeter using a 10mm socket with an extension. The housing will pull straight off. Keep a rag under it as trapped oil will drain out. Take the housing to a clean work surface.
5
Remove the old gasket and clean both surfaces
The old profile gasket sits in a groove in the housing. Use a pick tool to carefully remove it — it will be hard and shrunken. Clean both the housing mating surface and the engine block surface thoroughly with brake cleaner. Both surfaces must be completely oil-free and dry before installing the new gasket.
📷
Photo: old gasket removed from groove — show shrinkage and hardening of rubber
6
Check and service the non-return valve
Look inside the housing where the non-return valve sits. You'll see a plastic valve with fins. Check the surrounding aluminum bore for a groove worn by the fins. If a shallow groove is present, push the valve in and rotate it 30–60 degrees so the fins land on fresh aluminum, not the groove. If the groove is deep enough that the valve falls back, replace the entire housing.
Why this matters: If the non-return valve doesn't seat properly, oil drains back out of the housing when the engine is off. Every cold start runs for 3–4 seconds with no oil pressure. That's bearing wear accumulating every single time you start the car.
7
Install new gasket and reinstall housing
Press the new profile gasket firmly into the groove in the housing all the way around. Reinstall the housing on the engine, thread all bolts in by hand, then torque to 10 Nm in a star pattern. Reconnect the VANOS line with new crush washers — torque the banjo bolt to 25 Nm. Install a fresh oil filter and cap, torque the cap to 25 Nm.
8
Refill oil, start engine, check for leaks
Refill with fresh BMW LL-01 spec oil. Start the engine and let it idle. Watch the front of the engine where the housing is — it should be completely dry within 2–3 minutes of running. The oil pressure light should go out within 1–2 seconds on a warm restart. Check again after a 15 minute drive.
Success check: Clean dry housing, oil pressure light out in 1 second on warm restart, no oil smell after driving. You've fixed the most common oil leak on the M54.
Torque specs
Housing bolts
10 Nm
Star pattern — aluminum threads
VANOS banjo bolt
25 Nm
New crush washers both sides
Oil filter cap
25 Nm
New cap O-ring recommended
Oil drain plug
25 Nm
New washer each time
Since you're already in there...
Oil change — engine is already drained, do it now
Accessory belt inspection — fan clutch is already off, look at belt condition
Water pump — you have visibility and access from this position
VANOS solenoids — engine is apart, clean them while you're in there
Guide 12 Route B Intermediate

E46 Front Wheel Bearing —
Hub assembly swap, full procedure

Fits: 1999–2006 E46 RWD · 323i 325i 328i 330i — NOT Xi models
Time: 2–4 hours
Difficulty: Intermediate
Cost: $100–160 per side
Front wheel bearings on the E46 are sold as complete hub assemblies — the bearing is pressed into the hub at the factory and sold as one unit. You're swapping the entire hub, not just pressing in a bearing. This is actually easier than the traditional press-in method. Average bearing life is 80,000–100,000 miles. Do both sides if one is worn — they go at similar intervals.
Symptoms of a failing wheel bearing: Humming or roaring noise that changes with speed, changes pitch when turning slightly left or right, grinding or cyclic noise from the front end, vibration felt through the steering wheel at highway speed. A failed bearing can cause the hub to seize to the spindle — don't let it get that far.
Which side is bad: Load the bearing by turning while driving. Turn slightly left — if the noise gets louder, the left bearing is bad (load shifts to the outside of the turn). Turn slightly right — if noise gets louder, the right is bad. This isolates the failed side without a lift.
Parts list — pick your budget
Budget build · $80–100 per side
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
GSP front hub assembly (RWD E46)NB681516~$80ECS Tuning
New hub nut (single use)31211128336~$8Turner Motorsport
Total per side~$88
OEM quality · $120–140 per side
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
FAG front hub assembly (OEM supplier)31226757024~$115Turner Motorsport
New hub nut31211128336~$8Turner Motorsport
FAG is the OEM supplier to BMW — same bearing that came in the car from the factory
Total per side~$123
Tools required
46mm socket (deep)Hub nut — the big one
1/2" impact or breaker barHub nut is torqued to 290 Nm
17mm socketWheel bolts
16mm socketCaliper bolts
6mm hex bitRotor retaining screw
Slide hammer or hub pullerRemove stuck hub from spindle
Dremel or thin pullerInner race removal if seized
Center punchStake the hub nut when done
Torque wrench 0–300 NmHub nut must be torqued precisely
Anti-seizeApply to spindle before new hub
Xi models are completely different. This guide is for RWD E46 only — 323i, 325i, 328i, 330i. The 325xi and 330xi use a different hub design. Check your model before ordering parts.
Procedure
1
Loosen hub nut with car on the ground
Before jacking the car up, tap out the staked portion of the hub nut with a punch and remove the dust cap. Use a 46mm socket and a long breaker bar or impact gun to break the hub nut loose while the wheel is still on the ground providing resistance. This nut is torqued to 290 Nm — it's extremely tight.
290 Nm is massive. A typical 1/2" torque wrench maxes out around 250 Nm. You need either an impact gun or a very long breaker bar. The nut must be broken loose before the car is lifted.
2
Lift car, remove wheel, caliper, and rotor
Jack the car and support on stands. Remove the wheel (17mm). Remove the two 16mm caliper bolts and hang the caliper with wire from the strut — never let it hang by the brake hose. Remove the rotor retaining screw (6mm hex) and slide the rotor off.
📷
Photo: hub exposed with rotor removed — hub nut and spindle visible
3
Remove the hub nut and pull the hub assembly
With the nut removed, the hub assembly should slide off the spindle. If it's stuck, reinstall 2–3 wheel bolts and use them as pull points — rock and pull the hub toward you. Alternatively, a slide hammer attached to the wheel bolt holes provides controlled pulling force. Never hammer on the spindle or hub face.
Reinstall wheel bolts as handles: Thread 2–3 wheel bolts back into the hub flange. Grab them and pull firmly while rocking side to side. The hub will come free. This avoids the need for a slide hammer on most cars.
4
Remove the inner bearing race if stuck on the spindle
Sometimes when the hub pulls off, the inner bearing race stays behind on the spindle. This is common on high mileage or rusty cars. Use a thin two-jaw puller or carefully score the race with a Dremel cutting wheel (one light cut through the race) then pop it off with a screwdriver and hammer. Clean the spindle thoroughly with emery cloth once the race is off.
📷
Photo: inner race stuck on spindle — and Dremel score method for removal
5
Prep the spindle and install new hub
Clean the spindle surface with emery cloth until it's smooth. Apply a thin coat of anti-seize compound to the spindle to make future removal easier. Slide the new FAG hub assembly onto the spindle. Thread the new hub nut by hand as far as it will go — the nut will pull the hub onto the spindle as you torque it.
Anti-seize is your future self's gift. A light coat on the spindle means the next person doing this job can remove the hub without a Dremel and prayers. Takes 10 seconds. Do it.
6
Torque the hub nut and stake it
Torque the new hub nut to 290 Nm (214 ft-lbs). Once fully torqued, use a punch or chisel to stake the edge of the nut into the groove on the spindle — this locks the nut and prevents it from loosening. A staked hub nut is a safety feature. Do not skip this step.
New hub nut every time. The old nut has been staked and its locking ability is compromised. A $8 new nut is not negotiable. Never reuse a staked hub nut.
7
Reinstall rotor, caliper, and wheel
Reinstall the rotor, thread in the retaining screw finger tight. Reinstall the caliper and torque the bolts to 81 Nm. Reinstall the wheel and torque in a star pattern to 120 Nm. Lower the car and take a progressive test drive — the humming noise should be gone immediately.
Torque specs
Hub nut
290 Nm
New nut required · stake after torquing
Caliper bolts
81 Nm
Both bolts
Wheel bolts
120 Nm
Star pattern
Rotor retaining screw
12 Nm
6mm hex
Since you're already in there...
Brake pads and rotors — wheel is already off, check everything while you're here
Wheel speed sensor — inspect the ABS sensor and its wiring at the hub while it's off
Tie rod end — grab the tie rod and check for play while the wheel is off
Ball joint — check for play in the ball joint while the suspension is apart
Guide 13 Route A Total beginner

E46 Cabin Air Filter —
10 minutes, $25, skip the $100 dealer charge

Fits: 1999–2006 E46 · All models
Time: 10 minutes
Difficulty: Total beginner
Cost: $20–30
This is the easiest job on the entire car. No tools required. Ten minutes. The dealer charges $80–110 for this. The cabin filter (microfilter) cleans the air coming through your HVAC system. A clogged filter reduces airflow, causes musty smells, and lets allergens and exhaust particles into the cabin. Replace it every year or every 10,000 miles — sooner if you live somewhere dusty.
Which filter to choose: Standard paper filter ($18–22) does the job. Activated charcoal filter ($25–30) eliminates odors too — diesel exhaust, burning oil, Texas traffic. If your car ever smelled like burnt oil or exhaust inside, go charcoal. Worth the extra $8.
Parts list — pick your budget
Standard · $18–22
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
OEM microfilter — standard paper64311000004~$19Amazon
Mann OEM standard filterCU2939~$22Turner Motorsport
Total~$19–22
Activated charcoal · $25–30
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Mann charcoal cabin filter64319257504~$28Turner Motorsport
Eliminates exhaust odors, diesel smell, and burning oil smell from entering the cabin. Recommended.
Total~$28
Premium anti-allergen · $30–35
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Mann FreciousPlus anti-allergen filterFP2939~$32Turner Motorsport
Polyphenol bio-coating — filters 97% of allergens, mold, and bacteria. Best choice for allergy sufferers.
Total~$32
Procedure — no tools needed
1
Open the hood and find the filter housing
The cabin filter housing is located at the rear of the engine bay, up against the firewall near the windshield base. You'll see a plastic housing with three spring-loaded locking tabs. It's impossible to miss — it's the only thing back there with tabs on it.
📷
Photo: cabin filter housing location — three tabs visible at firewall
2
Twist the three locking tabs and lift the lid
Rotate each of the three tabs 90 degrees counter-clockwise to unlock them. Once all three are unlocked, lift the lid straight up and off. The lid separates from the housing cleanly — set it aside.
3
Slide the old filter out
The filter slides straight up out of the housing. Pull it out and look at the dirty side. A brown or gray filter means it was overdue. A filter with visible debris or mold means your cabin air quality has been terrible for some time. Dispose of the old filter immediately — the debris will fall back into the housing if you shake it around.
Clean the housing while you're in there. Use a lint-free rag to wipe out any debris, leaves, or dust from the housing before installing the new filter. Takes 30 seconds and keeps the new filter cleaner longer.
4
Install the new filter — orientation matters
The new filter has two plastic spikes/pins on one side. These go into the housing — they lock the filter in place. Slide the filter into the housing with the pins going in first. The filter should seat firmly with no gap around the edges. The airflow direction arrow on the filter should point toward the cabin.
Orientation matters. Installing the filter upside down or backwards means unfiltered air bypasses the filter entirely. The pins go inside the housing. Confirm the filter is fully seated before replacing the lid.
5
Replace the lid and lock the tabs
Place the lid back on and twist each of the three tabs 90 degrees clockwise to lock. That's it. Close the hood. Turn on your HVAC on full blast for 30 seconds — you'll immediately notice improved airflow and no musty smell. You just saved yourself $80.
What the dealer charges vs what this costs: BMW dealer charges $80–110 for this service. Parts cost $18–32. Time: 10 minutes. You do the math on how many times they've done this to you over the years.
Since you're already in there...
Engine air filter — while the hood is up, pop the airbox and check the engine filter too
VANOS solenoids — visible from this angle, give them a look
Coolant level — expansion tank is right there, check the level
Guide 14 Route A–B Beginner

E46 Power Steering —
Diagnosis, fluid check, and flush

Fits: 1999–2006 E46 · All models
Time: 30 min diagnosis · 1–2 hrs flush
Difficulty: Beginner
Cost: $20–50
Power steering leaks and whining are extremely common on high mileage E46s. The key is diagnosing the actual leak source before throwing money at it. The system has multiple failure points — reservoir, reservoir cap, return lines, pressure lines, pump, and rack. This guide walks through diagnosing the leak systematically and doing a full fluid flush.
Critical — identify your fluid type FIRST. E46s use either ATF (Dexron III) or Pentosin CHF 11S — check the label on your reservoir cap. They are NOT compatible. Mixing them destroys the seals in the pump and rack. Check the cap color and label before touching anything. ATF cap = red fluid. CHF 11S cap = green fluid.
Parts list — pick your budget
Fluid flush — ATF type · $15–20
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Dexron III ATF synthetic (1 qt)Mobil 1 ATF~$12Amazon
For ATF-equipped E46s only — check your reservoir cap
Total~$12
Fluid flush — CHF 11S type · $25–35
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Pentosin CHF 11S (1 liter)CHF11S-1~$28Amazon
For CHF 11S-equipped E46s only — check your reservoir cap first
Total~$28
Reservoir replacement · $35–50
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
PS reservoir (OEM replacement)32411097164~$40ECS Tuning
Replace if reservoir is cracked or O-ring on cap is leaking — common on high mileage E46s
Total~$40
Step 1 — Diagnose the leak source
1
Clean the entire power steering system
You cannot find a leak on a dirty engine. Get a can of engine degreaser, spray down the entire PS system — reservoir, hoses, pump, rack boots — and rinse clean. Let it dry completely. Now park over cardboard and drive the car for 15 minutes to warm everything up. Come back and look underneath for fresh fluid on the cardboard.
2
Check the reservoir and cap
The PS reservoir has an internal filter that cannot be serviced — only the reservoir itself can be replaced. Look for hairline cracks in the reservoir body and weeping around the cap O-ring. The cap O-ring fails frequently on high mileage E46s. A wet or oily cap area means the O-ring needs replacement.
📷
Photo: PS reservoir location in engine bay — cap dipstick and O-ring detail
3
Check the hose connections at the reservoir
Two hoses connect to the bottom of the reservoir. These hose connections are a very common leak point — look for weeping or oil residue around the connection points. Squeeze the hoses at the clamps — any cracking or softness means replace the hose.
4
Check the steering rack boots
Get underneath and squeeze the rubber boots on both ends of the steering rack. If you hear or feel fluid sloshing inside the boot, the rack seals are leaking. This is a more serious repair — the rack itself needs rebuilding or replacement. Rackdoctor.net does E46 rack rebuilds for a fraction of a new rack cost.
Rack seal failure = rack rebuild or replacement. There is no gasket you can replace from the outside on a leaking rack. Once fluid is in the boot, the rack seals are gone. Budget $300–500 for a rebuilt rack.
5
Fluid color diagnosis
Drop a few drops of PS fluid on white paper. ATF should be clear red or light amber — dark brown or black means severely degraded. CHF 11S should be clear green or light amber — dark or foamy means replace. Dark foamy fluid causes pump damage and rough steering feel. A fluid flush often resolves mild steering whine and heaviness.
Step 2 — Fluid flush procedure
1
Extract old fluid from reservoir
Use a turkey baster or fluid syringe to remove as much old fluid from the reservoir as possible. The reservoir has a dipstick on the underside of the cap — note the MIN and MAX marks. Extract until near the minimum level. Refill with fresh fluid of the correct type to the MAX mark.
2
Flush by cycling the steering
With the engine running, turn the steering wheel slowly from full left lock to full right lock five or six times. This pumps old fluid out of the lines and rack. Check the reservoir level and top off. Repeat until the fluid coming from the dipstick is clean and the correct color. This takes 1–2 liters of fresh fluid total.
Lift the front wheels for easier full lock cycling. With the car in the air, you can cycle lock-to-lock without fighting the weight of the car. Cycle slowly to avoid stressing the pump at full lock.
3
Check level and test drive
Check the fluid level with the engine warm — there are two marks, one for cold and one for warm. Top off to the correct warm mark. Test drive and check for improved steering feel and reduced whine. If whining continues after a flush, the pump itself may be failing.
Since you're already in there...
Inspect the PS pump belt — look for cracking, glazing, or fraying while you're under the hood
Check power steering hose clamps — loose clamps are the most common cause of reservoir leaks
Inspect the tie rod ends — you're looking at the steering rack area anyway
Guide 15 Route A Beginner

E46 Accessory Belt & Tensioner —
Pre-emptive strike before you're stranded

Fits: 1999–2006 E46 · M52TU · M54
Time: 1–2 hours
Difficulty: Beginner
Cost: $40–80
The E46 runs two serpentine belts — one for the alternator and one for the AC compressor. A broken accessory belt strands you immediately. The alternator belt also drives the power steering pump — lose it and you lose charging and power steering at once. Replace both belts at 60,000–80,000 miles proactively. The tensioner should be replaced at the same time.
Symptoms of worn belts: Squealing on startup (especially cold), squealing during sharp turns or when AC turns on, visible cracking or glazing on the belt surface, belt dust (black rubber powder) visible under the engine. Any of these means replace before it lets go.
Parts list — pick your budget
Budget build · $40–50
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Continental alternator belt (M54)6PK1548~$18Amazon
Continental AC belt (M54)4PK890~$12Amazon
Belt tensioner (OEM style)11281741369~$22Amazon
Total~$52
OEM quality · $65–80
PartPart NumberPriceWhere to buy
Gates alternator beltK060610~$22ECS Tuning
Gates AC compressor beltK040350~$15ECS Tuning
INA tensioner assembly11281741369~$38ECS Tuning
Total~$75
Tools required
15mm socket + breaker barTensioner bolt — releases belt tension
10mm socketBelt guard/shroud bolts if present
T50 TorxSome tensioner bolts are Torx
FlashlightBelt routing is tight to see
Phone cameraPhotograph belt routing before removal
Procedure
1
Photograph the belt routing before touching anything
Take a clear photo of both belts showing exactly how they route around all pulleys. This takes 10 seconds and will save you from a frustrating puzzle when it's time to reinstall. Belt routing is not always obvious and the diagram in the repair manual is hard to read.
📷
Photo: both belts with routing arrows — alternator belt path and AC belt path
2
Inspect belts before removing
With the engine off, look closely at both belts. Run your finger along the inside (ribbed surface) — any cracking means replace immediately. Look at the back (smooth surface) for glazing or shiny spots — glazed belts slip and squeal. Check for fraying at the belt edges. Any one of these defects is reason to replace.
3
Release AC belt tension and remove AC belt first
Use a 15mm socket on the AC tensioner bolt and push to release tension. The tensioner pivots on a bolt — pushing it compresses the spring and loosens the belt. Slip the belt off the AC compressor pulley first, then route it off the other pulleys. The AC belt is the shorter of the two.
AC belt goes first because it sits between the two belts. You can't remove the alternator belt without the AC belt out of the way.
4
Release alternator belt tension and remove alternator belt
The alternator tensioner is a separate unit — also 15mm. Release tension and slip the alternator belt off. Note the routing carefully before it comes all the way off. The alternator belt runs around the crankshaft pulley, water pump pulley, alternator, and tensioner.
5
Replace the tensioner
With both belts off, the tensioner is now easily accessible. Remove the central bolt and pull the tensioner off. Compare with the new unit — if the spring in the old tensioner has any play or the pulley wobbles, you made the right call replacing it. A failed tensioner can throw a belt at speed.
Replace the tensioner at every belt change. The tensioner spring fatigues over time and no longer maintains correct belt tension. A loose belt slips, squeals, and generates heat. The tensioner costs $22–38. It's not optional on a 100k+ mile car.
6
Install new belts in reverse order
Install the alternator belt first using your reference photo for routing. Route it around all pulleys except the tensioner pulley last. Use the 15mm to compress the tensioner while you seat the belt on the tensioner pulley. Release the tensioner — belt should be firm with no slack. Repeat for the AC belt.
Belt tension check: With the engine off, try to twist the longest span of the alternator belt. You should be able to rotate it about 90 degrees. More than that means too loose. Less means too tight. The tensioner sets this automatically — just make sure it's seating properly.
7
Start engine and listen
Start the engine and listen for squealing. New belts sometimes squeal briefly for the first few starts as they seat in. Turn the AC on and off — if the AC belt squeals when the compressor kicks in, it may be slightly loose. Turn the steering wheel full lock — power steering should be smooth and quiet with the new alternator belt.
Since you're already in there...
Water pump — belts and fan are already off, this is the lowest labor cost time to do it
Oil filter housing gasket — fan is already off, easiest access you'll have
Power steering pump inspection — look at the pump while the belt is off, check for leaks at the shaft seal
Alternator — grab it and check for side-to-side play, and inspect the wiring